National Campaign to Restore Civil Rights

Students Deserve Residency Not Deportation

By Ricardo Sánchez
National Campaign to Restore Civil Rights guest blogger on immigration and education

U.S. Department of Homeland Security chief, Michael Chertoff, proclaims these days that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents are doing all they can to “control our borders,” part of which entails workplace enforcement.

Truth is, since well before World War II, immigration authorities have, at best, selectively enforced our laws. Selectively means, for one, not straying into agricultural fields during harvest seasons. To be fair, agriculture is only one of many industries that have thrived using undocumented workers—count hotels, restaurants, forestry, fishing, construction, roofing and others in the mix.

So that taxpayers believe immigration officials are vigilant in their duties, periodically we see television footage of workplace raids where a handful of workers are detained.

But what we don’t see or hear about is more telling. None of us heard two weeks ago of ICE agents apprehending an 18-year old at a south Seattle-area apartment complex while getting into her car to go to high school, did we?

They guessed right. She was in the U.S without legal papers. Without providing or ensuring that she had legal advice, this frightened young woman went before a judge just last week to be told that she could leave the country voluntarily, or face further detainment and a hearing at a later date. She chose to leave the country—dreams dashed for this high school senior who aspires to become a doctor.

Ah, another victory for ICE and U.S. taxpayers.

We’re easily duped. No, worse—we’re silently assenting to duplicitous immigration practices that keep immigration agents at bay during harvest seasons. Why? Because for consumers, it ensures we continue to pay lower prices for agricultural products than any industrialized nation in the world.

If Chertoff and ICE were to take their job of “controlling our borders” seriously, they would be conducting raids in the apple fields of eastern Washington even as you read this article. They know, however, that members of our own congressional delegation would intervene to stop the raids, just as they have in recent years in Washington and across the nation.

The reason: ill-timed raids would spell economic ruin for our state’s largest tree-fruit industry—valued at more than a billion dollars annually. Washington grows well over half of the apples consumed in our nation. The stakes are large.

But individuals in bus stops, or student scholars on their way to school, remain fair game.
It’s been this way for decades, but it’s not my version of “The American Way.”

If that ideal guided the national conscience, we would stand collectively and say to Michael Chertoff and the Congress: Until and unless you are willing to enforce our laws, no exemptions for industries with powerful friends, keep your hands off innocent young people, especially promising students whose only “wrong” was obeying their parents when they were brought into the country, some as infants.

One would hope that if the nation’s top lawmakers can force the administrative agencies to not enforce our laws during select times of the year—and they do—they might also find the courage and compassion to help deserving student scholars who want to obtain college degrees and contribute to our nation as law abiding citizens that they now only can dream about.

Ricardo Sánchez is chair of the Latino/a Educational Achievement Project, and is a U.S. citizen who lives in Seattle. He can be reached at

National Campaign to Restore Civil Rights: Author Bio | Other Posts
Posted at 12:28 PM, Oct 31, 2007 in Civil Justice | Immigration
Permalink | Email to Friend


They do have very good medical schools in Mexico. I've known US citizens who have gotten their degrees down there because it is cheaper to go to medical school in Mexico than in the US. When the US students receive their medical degree in Mexico and returned to practice in the US they still had to take all of the tests here in the US when they came back to get licensed.

Posted by: Ann | October 31, 2007 6:18 PM Now you want to tell me how nice and good and sweet illegal aliens are EZ? I grew up in Yakima left in 1984 came back home in 2003 and it's now a (amnesty was great for Yakima and sunnyside) 3rd world country! if you would get all your aliens out of the yakima factories you would have your apple pickers dirt bag.

Posted by: Biff | October 31, 2007 9:32 PM

Biff: You spit into the wind. Kia and her puppet masters are lawyers. All lawyers are criminal lovers. The criminal generates lawyer jobs and fees. You are asking the criminal lover lawyer to increase their unemployment by reducing crime.

Posted by: Supremacy Claus | November 1, 2007 2:52 PM

BIFF: you are confusing BROWN PERSON with ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT. But I'm not surprised. Your first link makes NO MENTION of the teenagers' residential status, no where does it say that these kids aren't U.S. citizens. But I guess their last names allowed you to jump to the conclusion that they are undocumented? At any rate, I guess these two instances are cause for making conclusions about all undocumented people? Right... The ignorance sickens me.

Posted by: Disgusted | November 8, 2007 10:36 AM