Cyrus Dugger

Apology Not Accepted

Today’s NY Times Editorial…

Apology Not Accepted It is hard to render a convincing apology when you are not really apologizing. Consider Charles Stimson, the deputy assistant secretary of state for detainee affairs, who has been trying to spin his way out of his loathsome attempt to punish lawyers who represent inmates of the Guantánamo Bay internment camp.

Last week, Mr. Stimson expressed his “shock” that major American law firms would represent terrorism suspects, hinted that they were paid by unsavory characters and suggested that companies should reconsider doing business with them. On Wednesday, Mr. Stimson said he apologized and regretted that his comments “left the impression” that he was attacking the integrity of those lawyers.

It was not just an impression. It was exactly what he did. Mr. Stimson actually read out a list of law firms during an interview with a radio station friendly to the Bush administration.

Mr. Stimson clearly had no regard for his position as a public official who helps set policy on the detainees, never mind the small matter of people’s basic right to representation. He connected the detainees to the 9/11 attacks, even though he certainly knows that the very few detainees who have a connection to 9/11 don’t have legal representation.

President Bush and Defense Secretary Robert Gates should have fired him. Their silence was deafening, although hardly surprising given the administration’s record of trampling on people’s rights in the name of fighting terror. (keep reading)

Mr. Stimson’s appalling behavior should not be overlooked by the relevant bar disciplinary committee. Existing rules for lawyers deem it professional misconduct to do things that are prejudicial to the administration of justice. Even if the administration does not, the legal profession imposes a higher duty on those holding public office to obey proper standards of behavior. (keep reading)

Posted at 4:04 PM, Jan 19, 2007 in Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)